Sister Sheila was a nun in the same convent as Sister Ingalls and Sister Mary Eunice when they were both novices. She appears solely in Sister Ingalls' flashbacks in "Take a Break From Your Values". She is portrayed by Hayley Treider.
Sister Sheila is shown to be naive and a follower of Sister Mary Eunice.
Sister Sheila wears an unrevealing nun outfit which shows a small amount of her blonde hair. Besides this she has full checks and thin lips.
Before Sister Ingalls's incarceration
Sister Ingalls meets Sister Sheila and Sister Mary Eunice when they discuss stopping the war in Vietnam. Sister Ingalls seems interested in this, and runs over to ask what's happening. Sister Mary Eunice informs Sister Ingalls of the rally that is happening in Washington. Sister Mary Eunice offers a leaflet to Sister Ingalls as Sister Sheila stands by. Sister Sheila says that she didn't realise that nuns are allowed to read newspapers, Sister Ingalls agrees and tells Sister Mary Eunice to put the leaflets away as they do not have the veil. After Sister Mary Eunice says Sister Constance gave her permission to, Sister Ingalls and Sister Sheila agree to go along with Sister Mary Eunice.
After returning from the rally, Sister Sheila, Sister Ingalls and Sister Mary Eunice exit a Volkswagen van and thank the driver. They return, and Sister Mary Eunice reveals that they did not actually have permission from Sister Constance. Sister Sheila is visibly anxious about being in trouble, saying she has "fallen in with the bad nuns". ("Take a Break From Your Values")
|Orange Is the New Black: Season Two|
|"Thirsty Bird":||"Looks Blue, Tastes Red":||"Hugs Can Be Deceiving":||"A Whole Other Hole":||"Low Self Esteem City":||"You Also Have a Pizza":||"Comic Sans":|
|"Appropriately Sized Pots":||"40 Oz. of Furlough":||"Little Mustachioed Shit":||"Take a Break From Your Values":||"It Was the Change":||"We Have Manners. We're Polite.":|